Kitchen Sink Peanut Butter Cookies (3 Ways)

Remember my homemade peanut butter?




I’d be surprised if you were able to forget about it!  I sure haven’t and as promised, I am delivering the third recipe installment of my Peanut Butter Month series.  Ok, that makes this sound way more serious and planned out than it is (and I sincerely apologize if you are allergic to peanuts), but the game plan is to share 4 new peanut butter recipes this month.  Here goes Number 3…




Since I’ve already made brownies and bars, it seemed fitting that this next recipe be for soft, chewy, and loaded peanut butter cookies.  Last night, I was dipping some leftover pretzels into the jar for a taste.  The salty contrast of the pretzel with the sweet peanut butter was divine, and I knew there should be pretzels in my cookies.  Not too long after that I found inspiration on Mercedes Blog.  Her cookies are based on a Rachael Ray recipe that I’ve actually made before.  It combines the deliciousness of peanut butter cookies with some of your sweet and salty favorites.




How could you go wrong?  I used my homemade peanut butter to create the peanut butter dough.




Then stirred in chocolate chips, white chocolate chips, and chopped honey roasted peanuts.  Basically a whole bunch of things from my pantry. Hence the title of this post…




The game plan was to roll the cookies in the pretzels…


IMG_9285 IMG_9290


Which was sticky business because my cookie scooper is busted.




Total bummer, I know, but I still got some pretty rounded balls with a half scooper/half hand rolling approach.




After about 20 cookies, I ran out of pretzels.  I did a pretty good job of stretching out what I had, but I knew it wasn’t going to be enough.  I didn’t have a backup plan and still had plenty of dough leftover, so I chopped up the rest of my peanuts and rolled the dough balls in them.


IMG_9313 IMG_9316


Until I ran out of peanuts.  By the time I got to the bottom of my bowl, the dough was a little thinner and had less of the chocolate chips.  I rolled this last dozen or so in sugar like a typical peanut butter cookie.


IMG_9323 IMG_9330


All varieties baked for about 12 minutes, give or take the time it took me to get organized and lick the bowl, spatula, and spoon completely clean. 




These cookies turned out beautifully!  The first 2 kinds (pretzel and peanut) were soft and chewy with gooey chocolate chips on the inside and a salty finish.


IMG_9318 IMG_9338


The sugar coated cookies spread WAY out but are crisp and delish!




One cookie recipe = Three incredible results


#1 Topped with Pretzels




#2 Rolled in Honey Roasted Peanuts




#3 Crunchy and Sugar Coated




Either way, you can’t go wrong. So pick your favorite OR just make them all!




I now have dozens of cookies to share with my family and friends for the holiday this week.  And historically, my PB cookies have stored well in the freezer.  The only sad news of the evening…




We are all out of peanut butter!




To round off the celebration, the last peanut butter recipe will be here next week.  That’s the prefect amount of time for me to find help devouring my pile of cookies and come up with something new to make…Any suggestions?


What is your favorite peanut butter cookie recipe?

Share your links!



Double Chip Peanut Butter Cookies (3 ways)

Recipe from Satisfy My Sweet Tooth



1 1/2 cup flour

1/2 tsp baking soda

1 1/2 sticks (12 Tbsp) unsalted butter, at room temperature

1 1/4 cups sugar

1 cup creamy peanut butter (I suggest honey roasted)

2 eggs, at room temperature

1/2 cup milk chocolate chips

1/2 cup white chocolate chips

1/2 cup chopped honey roasted peanuts


Toppings (choose one or all):

1 cup crushed pretzels, 1 cup chopped honey roasted peanuts, and 3/4 cups sugar for rolling



Preheat oven to 350°.

In a large bowl, combine butter, sugar and peanut butter and beat with an electric mixer until light and fluffy. Add eggs and mix until combined. Add flour and baking soda and mix until combined. Mix in chocolate chips, white chocolate chips, and peanuts.

Place remaining crushed pretzels, peanuts, and sugar in a small separate bowls. Using a medium-sized ice cream scoop, drop balls of dough into crushed pretzels (or other toppings) and roll lightly to coat. Then place onto cookie sheet.

Bake 12 minutes. Cool on racks.

Store in airtight container or freezer in freezer safe ziploc bag.

10 thoughts on “Kitchen Sink Peanut Butter Cookies (3 Ways)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s